If you're seeking the best auto insurance coverage you should first look at your needs and budget. Most independent insurance agents, including InsuraMatch, work with multiple insurance carriers so that you can compare prices and services across multiple companies. InsuraMatch works with many of the best carriers in New York, including Progressive, 21st Century, Mercury and Foremost.

Most insurance customers typically refer to coverage quality and pricing when shopping for the best auto insurance. In an independent survey by LightSpeed Research, more than 3,000 insurance customers of 18 different insurance carriers were polled on coverage and cost. The 2014 survey showed customers gave these carriers high ratings across the board in these categories.

Here's are the highlights:

  • 21st Century: In terms of quality of coverage, more than 2 out of 3 respondents gave 21st Century 4 or 5 stars (out of a total of five stars) for this carrier. A total of 36.4 percent gave the carrier five stars for price, followed by 35.9 percent who gave 21st Century four stars.
  • Progressive: More than 36 percent gave the carrier four stars and 39 percent gave them five stars in terms of price. Nearly three out of four customers said they were comfortable with the coverage they had.
  • Mercury Insurance: More than 42 percent of Mercury customers gave quality of coverage a four star rating and almost 36 percent gave five stars. About 3 out of four customers also ranked Mercury highly for price satisfaction.

Results for Foremost are unavailable as the survey focused on major auto carriers and not specialty carriers, like Foremost.

How To Get Quotes From These Carriers

You can contact each carrier individually or use an online insurance portal like InsuraMatch to get multiple pricing at once. When you fill out the quote form, InsuraMatch securely provides your information so that these New York carriers will give you a quote result, similar to how you would search a travel portal for best airline ticket costs.

You can compare their services and price and call an InsuraMatch agent at 844-232-2700 who will help you set up your policy with these carriers and answer your questions.

Carriers with the best discounts

The InsuraMatch quote form will help identify most of the discounts you may qualify for but talking to an agent may help you find more. For instance, if you decide to bundle multiple policies, such as  your renters, home or umbrella insurance, you may save more on your insurance premiums.

Carriers also offer discounts if you have multiple cars on one policy or safety devices on your vehicle. Some of these discounts can add up to significant savings over the life of your policy.

Get free NY and Pennsylvania car insurance quotes online or contact InsuraMatch at 855-244-7671 to see how much we can help you save.